How Cabo Bali Compares to Other Villa Managers: Identical Villas on AirDNA

How Cabo Bali Compares to Other Villa Managers: Identical Villas on AirDNA

How does Cabo Bali compare to other villa managers? We tested it in three developments in Bali where identical villas sit side by side and are run by different managers. On AirDNA, our villas earn about twice as much per available night in Uluwatu, 35% more in one Bingin development and 21% more in another. Same design, same street, same market. The only real difference is who manages them. This page shows the AirDNA screens for all three, the method, and where we think the gap comes from. Cabo Bali manages private pool villas across Uluwatu, Bingin and Canggu.

Published 9 November 2026, updated 20 November 2026 | 9 min read | By Keanu Fischell, Co-Founder, Cabo Bali | Data: AirDNA, viewed 5 and 20 November 2026

Short answer

  • Uluwatu, 8 identical 3-bedroom villas: Cabo Bali's villa earns $235 per available night (91% occupancy at $258.8). The other villas average about $117 (70% at $167). About 2x.
  • Bingin, 4 identical 2-bedroom villas: Cabo Bali's villa earns $135 per available night (79% at $170.9). The other three average about $100 (70% at $150). 35% more.
  • Bingin, 8 identical 1-bedroom villas (Luro Villas): Cabo Bali's four villas earn $133 per available night on average (91.5% occupancy at $144.9). The other four average about $110 (75% at $145.9). 21% more, at the same nightly price.
  • The source is AirDNA, an independent short-term rental data company. We do not control any figure in it, and you can check every one yourself.
  • Where the gap comes from: on sale sooner, on more booking channels, prices set daily against the market, more reviews, and maintenance done in-house.

Three developments, at a glance

Each test compares villas of the same design, size and build, in the same development, so the manager is the main thing that differs. Here is every test we can run today.

DevelopmentIdentical villasCabo BaliOther managersGap
Uluwatu (Solas), 3-bed8 (1 Cabo, 7 others)$235$117About 2x
Bingin (Las Mimosas), 2-bed4 (1 Cabo, 3 others)$135$100+35%
Bingin (Luro Villas), 1-bed8 (4 Cabo, 4 others)$133$110+21%

Figures are revenue per available night: occupancy times the daily rate, from AirDNA. In every one of the three, the Cabo Bali villas are the most booked.

Why we publish this

Every villa manager in Bali says it gets better results. Very few show them, and almost none show them against a fair comparison. The fairest comparison there is: identical villas, built by the same developer, handed over at the same time, on the same street, run by different managers. Location, design, size and build quality are the same, so what is left is management.

‍

We use AirDNA rather than our own reports because owners should not have to take our word for it. AirDNA is what investors and lenders use to value short-term rentals, and it estimates every listing the same way, ours included.

Uluwatu (Solas): 8 identical 3-bedroom villas, one managed by Cabo Bali

Eight identical 3-bedroom villas with saunas, in one development in Uluwatu, with keys handed over in the same month. Seven owners went with the manager the developer recommended. One owner came to us. He already had a villa with a large Bali manager, and chose a boutique manager for his second.

AirDNA listing cards for 8 identical 3-bedroom villas in one Uluwatu development. The Cabo Bali villa earns $235 revenue per available night (91% occupancy at $258.8) vs about $117 for the other villas.
AirDNA, South Kuta/Bukit Peninsula, viewed 5 November 2026. We placed the eight listing cards side by side, faded the AirDNA menus and added the circles and the revenue bar. Every number is AirDNA's.
VillaOccupancyDaily ratePer available night
Cabo Bali91%$258.8$235
Villa 281%$151.8$123
Villa 378%$162.6$127
Villa 476%$179.2$136
Villa 568%$172.0$117
Villa 659%$173.3$102
Villa 758%$163.0$95
Villa 81 night booked$124.0Left out
Other villas, average70%$167$117

What stands out: our villa charges the highest rate of the eight and is still the fullest. It has been on sale for 152 days; the others for 30 to 91 days, even though all eight were handed over in the same month. It is the only one of the eight on Booking.com as well as Airbnb, and it has 12 reviews at 5.0 where no other villa has more than 3.

Bingin (Las Mimosas): 4 identical 2-bedroom villas, one managed by Cabo Bali

Four identical 2-bedroom villas listed on AirDNA in one Bingin development. Three are run by other managers, one by us. Here all four are on Airbnb and Booking.com, so channels are not the difference. Pricing and reviews are.

AirDNA listing cards for 4 identical 2-bedroom villas in one Bingin development. The Cabo Bali villa earns $135 revenue per available night (79% occupancy at $170.9) vs about $100 for the other villas.
AirDNA, South Kuta/Bukit Peninsula, viewed 5 November 2026. Cards placed side by side and marked by us; every number is AirDNA's.
VillaOccupancyDaily ratePer available night
Cabo Bali (Las Mimosas)79%$170.9$135
Villa 273%$160.5$117
Villa 352%$197.6$103
Villa 486%$92.8$80
Other villas, average70%$150$100

What stands out: one neighbour charges $198 and sits half empty. Another is the fullest of the four at 86%, but only because it sells its nights at $93, so it earns the least. Ours holds $171 and still fills 79% of its nights. It has 4.9 stars from 7 reviews; the others have 2 reviews or none.

Bingin (Luro Villas): 8 identical 1-bedroom villas, four managed by Cabo Bali

Luro Villas is a development in Bingin with eight identical 1-bedroom villas, each with a private pool. Cabo Bali manages four of them. The other four are run by two other Bali managers. This is the largest test of the three: four villas on each side, the same design, the same street, and almost the same nightly price.

AirDNA listing cards for 8 identical 1-bedroom villas at Luro Villas in Bingin. The four Cabo Bali villas earn $133 revenue per available night on average (91.5% occupancy at $144.9) vs about $110 for the four villas run by other managers.
AirDNA, South Kuta/Bukit Peninsula, viewed 20 November 2026. Top row: the four Cabo Bali villas. Bottom row: the four villas run by other managers. Two of those villas are sold on one shared listing, so its card appears twice. Cards placed side by side and marked by us; every number is AirDNA's.
VillaOccupancyDaily ratePer available night
Cabo Bali villa 192%$147.3$136
Cabo Bali villa 292%$145.8$134
Cabo Bali villa 393%$143.5$133
Cabo Bali villa 489%$143.0$127
Other villa 185%$153.2$130
Other villa 281%$141.6$115
Other villa 3 (shared listing)67%$144.4$97
Other villa 4 (shared listing)67%$144.4$97
Cabo Bali, average91.5%$144.9$133
Other villas, average75%$145.9$110

What stands out: the price is the same. All eight villas sell their nights for between $141 and $153. The difference is how many nights get sold. Every one of our four villas is booked 89% to 93% of its nights; none of the other four gets above 85%. The closest neighbour only matches us by charging the highest rate in the development. Two of the other villas are sold on one shared Airbnb listing, and that listing fills 67% of its nights.

Where we do better, and why

An identical villa cannot earn twice as much by luck. These are the five things we see making the difference, in order of how much money they move.

‍

1. On sale from day one. Every night a new villa is not listed is income that never comes back. Our own inspection team takes the villa at developer handover, and photos, listings and pricing are ready the same week. In Uluwatu our villa was on sale for 152 days; the neighbours, handed over the same month, for 30 to 91.

‍

2. More channels, not one. A villa only on Airbnb waits for Airbnb guests. Ours goes on Airbnb, Booking.com (with Genius status) and our own direct booking site, so a guest who never opens Airbnb can still find it. In Uluwatu it is the only one of eight on Booking.com.

‍

3. Prices set every day, against the market. We price with PriceLabs against a set of comparable villas, checked by a person and by AI every day. That is how a villa avoids both mistakes in the Las Mimosas table: charging $198 and sitting half empty, or filling up at $93 and giving the nights away. At Luro Villas it shows the other way round: the same price as the neighbours, sold on more nights.

‍

4. Reviews that sell the next booking. Guests book the villa with 12 reviews over the one with none. Our concierge team answers guests within 15 minutes, from 9am to 10pm, and is paid a bonus on review quality. Every villa we manage runs as a Superhost listing, shot by some of Bali's best villa photographers.

‍

5. Fixes done in-house, fast. In the Bingin building the power supply is weak, which trips the hot water in every villa. Our in-house team fixed the hot water set-up on ours; the same building, the same weak power, a different result for guests. Our engineers are full-time and can reach any villa we manage within 30 minutes.

Pro tip from Keanu: When you compare managers, never compare total revenue. A villa listed for 150 days will always beat one listed for 60. Compare revenue per available night: occupancy times the daily rate. It is the one number that is fair to both.

A second, independent source

PriceLabs, the pricing software we use, published its own case study on one of our 2-bedroom Bingin villas against its local comp set: 96.3% occupancy vs 79.8%, $203 vs $186 average daily rate, and $196 vs $148 revenue per available night. Read the PriceLabs customer story. Two different data companies, two different methods, the same direction.

How we measured it

  1. In AirDNA, open Short-term Rentals and search Bali, South Kuta/Bukit Peninsula.
  2. Filter by bedrooms (3 for Solas, 2 for Las Mimosas, 1 for Luro Villas) and property type, then zoom the map to the development's street.
  3. Pick every listing in that development with the same design and bedroom count, matched by photos and layout.
  4. Read AirDNA's occupancy and daily rate from each listing card, viewed on 5 November 2026 (Solas, Las Mimosas) and 20 November 2026 (Luro Villas).
  5. Work out revenue per available night: occupancy times daily rate.
  6. Average the other villas with a simple mean. Leave out any listing with too little history to measure (one Uluwatu villa had 1 night booked). Where two villas are sold on one shared listing, count that listing's figure once for each villa.

Occupancy in AirDNA counts booked nights against nights the listing was open, so revenue per available night is fair to villas that have been listed for different lengths of time. AirDNA's figures are estimates built from public calendar and listing data, the same way for every listing, ours included. We do not name the developments' other managers. This is a comparison of numbers, not of companies.

When this is not the whole story

It is three developments, not every villa in Bali. These are the places where we manage villas next to identical ones run by others, so they are the only fair tests we have. We show all three, including Luro Villas, where the gap is the smallest.

‍

A shared listing is an estimate. At Luro Villas two villas run by another manager are sold on one Airbnb listing. AirDNA reads that listing as one calendar, so the figure we show for each of the two villas is the listing's, not a measured per-villa number.

‍

AirDNA estimates can be off. It cannot see why a calendar is closed. An owner blocking dates for their own stay looks like a quiet villa.

‍

It is a snapshot. The figures are from 5 and 20 November 2026 and will move. Newer listings in Uluwatu may close part of the gap as they collect reviews.

‍

Gross is not what the owner keeps. Fees and running costs come off. To see what an owner actually receives, read our real 12-month owner P&L.

Check it yourself

It takes about two minutes with a free AirDNA account. Search Bali, then South Kuta/Bukit Peninsula. For Uluwatu, filter to 3 bedrooms, zoom the map to Jl. Labuansait and find "3BR Solas Villa | Sauna | Ice Bath". For Bingin, switch to 2 bedrooms, zoom to Bingin and find "Las Mimosas". For Luro Villas, switch to 1 bedroom, zoom to Jl. Jepun Sari in Bingin and find the listings named "Luro Villas". Then look at the identical villas around them.

Want this for your villa? Send us your listing or your renders and the exact Google Maps pin. We will show you the comparable villas on your street, what they earn, and honestly whether we are the right fit. Get your proposal → Or read how Cabo Bali manages villas: 13% of gross plus IDR 2.5M a month, no lock-in, 90 days' notice.

FAQ

How does Cabo Bali compare to other villa management companies in Bali?

On identical villas side by side on AirDNA in three developments (November 2026), Cabo Bali earns $235 per available night against about $117 for the other villas in one Uluwatu development, $135 against about $100 in a 2-bedroom Bingin development, and $133 against about $110 across four villas each in the 1-bedroom Luro Villas development in Bingin. That is about 2x, 35% more and 21% more.

Why compare revenue per available night and not total revenue?

Total revenue depends on how long a villa has been listed. Revenue per available night (occupancy times the daily rate) is fair to villas listed for different lengths of time, so it isolates how well each one is run.

Where does the difference come from?

Five things: being on sale from handover, listing on Airbnb, Booking.com and direct rather than one channel, pricing every day against the market, building reviews faster, and fixing problems with an in-house maintenance team.

Do Cabo Bali villas only win by charging more?

No. At Luro Villas in Bingin all eight identical villas sell their nights for between $141 and $153. Cabo Bali's four are booked 89% to 93% of their nights; the other four 67% to 85%. Same price, more nights sold.

Can I check these numbers myself?

Yes. With a free AirDNA account, search Bali, South Kuta/Bukit Peninsula, filter by bedrooms, zoom the map to the development and compare the identical listings. Figures will have moved since November 2026.

Are AirDNA figures accurate?

They are estimates from public calendar and listing data, made the same way for every listing, ours included. AirDNA cannot see owner blocks, so a villa the owner uses often can look quieter than it is.

Is this a promise of what my villa will earn?

No. It is the past performance of six villas in three developments against identical neighbours. Your villa's result depends on its location, design, pricing and the market. We will show you the comparable villas on your street before you decide.

Want our Bali guides first when you search? Add Cabo Bali as a preferred source on Google.

Add Cabo Bali on Google